Recipes

Grandma's Chicken Soup

By Adam Siegel
 

Adam Siegel 

 

Transporting diners to countries far from the Lake Michigan shore is what Adam Siegel has been doing for the past few decades. He first gained local fame as the James Beard Award-winning chef at Bartolotta-owned French spot Lake Park Bistro. After a long tenure with The Bartolotta Restaurants, he left to open his own place, Lupi & Iris, whose menu is inspired by the cuisines of the French and Italian rivieras.

After hanging up his chef’s coat for the night at Lupi, the Chicago native enters the culinary domain of home. There, the food has an intrinsically different feel to it. He’s both the classically trained chef and the grandson simmering up history in a stockpot. To Siegel, the process of making chicken soup feels like the best kind of exercise. “I like chicken with noodles, chicken with rice, and my absolute favorite is chicken matzo ball soup,” he says. The chicken soup recipe he uses is his grandmother’s. It was handwritten in her recipe book and has a history of its own. “She probably learned it from her family over the years,” he says. Many, many years of chicken soup-making. Siegel’s grandmother’s ancestors came from Austria, and she was the first in her family born in the United States. “It’s deeply rooted in European cooking methods and Ashkenazi Jewish history,” he says. It’s a favorite dish of Siegel’s wife. It’s a favorite of his daughter. It’s something that loves the freezer. It, of course, loves to be eaten immediately. Siegel loves it “garnished with a lot of carrots, for sweetness.” White rice bumps up the heartiness. Wild rice, he says, makes it extra delicious – chewy and almost smoky. “It warms the body and soul,” he says.

To get the most out of his chicken, Siegel cuts the breast meat away from the carcass and trims the leg and thigh down. After cooking, he takes those pieces out so they don’t get dry. He either uses the meat to garnish the soup or saves it for a “great” chicken salad.

 

Ingredients

Serves 4 to 6

1 3- to 4-pound chicken, or capon

1/2 pound chicken feet

4 stalks celery, diced large

5 medium carrots, peeled, diced large

1 medium onion, diced large

1 head garlic

1 medium parsnip, peeled, diced large

3 bay leaves

1 1/2 tablespoon kosher salt

1/4 teaspoon cracked black pepper

1/4 bunch dill

1/4 bunch Italian parsley

2 1/2 gallons purified or filtered water

Instructions

Rinse chicken and feet thoroughly. Place in a stainless-steel stock/soup pot. Cover with the water and add the salt. Put on medium heat. As the water is heating, continually skim off the foam that gradually forms at the top. Once the water reaches a simmer, add in all remaining ingredients. Leave at a light simmer, stirring occasionally. Let simmer three hours. Strain and check seasoning.

Either cool down or serve with matzo balls and/or the following: kreplach, egg noodles, simmered carrots and/or celery (cooked in the stock). Also great with wild or white rice added. You can also remove the meat and vegetables and combine it with mayonnaise and seasonings to make a chicken salad. Or you can garnish the soup with the picked chicken meat.

Bio

Chef and owner Adam Siegel attended the culinary school at Kendall College in Chicago and has been cooking professionally for over 30 years. Siegel’s expertise is in Mediterranean cuisine, and he has worked in celebrated restaurants throughout the United States and Italy. His passion is in creating simple, beautiful, delicious dishes that delight diners. Siegel moved to Milwaukee in 2000 to take the role of executive chef at Lake Park Bistro, where, in 2008, he won the prestigious James Beard Award for Best Chef Midwest. Soon after, Siegel took on the responsibility of overseeing the culinary staff and menus for The Bartolotta Restaurants as their corporate executive chef. In 2021, Siegel partnered with real estate developer and architect Michael DeMichele to create Lupi & Iris. Both Siegel and DeMichele are passionate about providing an extraordinary fine dining experience to Milwaukee diners.

Adam Siegel

Lupi & Iris

Adam Siegel

Lupi & Iris

View More Recipes By Chef Siegel

You might also like these unique Milwaukee-loved things

See All Recipes